It’s Wednsday again, and this week I’ve got a post for you about mysteries set on (usually small) islands. This is a popular setting for detective stories because it gives you a clear group of suspects who can’t escape the investigation. I’m doing this today because the latest Lady Hardcastle mystery came out yesterday and so I’m going to start there with something new!
Murder on the Rocks by T E Kinsey*

This is the thirteenth in Kinsey’s Edwardian-set series featuring a female crime fighting duo. In Murder on the Rocks Lady H and faithful Florence are spending a weekend on an island off the Devon coast when (as often happens) murder happens. The weather means they are trapped on the island with no hope of police assistance and so they promptly set out to solve the crime themselves. This has got a good group of characters as suspects as well as our intrepid duo and this is probably the smallest of the islands on this post with the least amount of people and buildings – meaning they really are cut off from assistance. It’s a fun and cozy read but with plenty of twists to keep you guessing about who might have done what.
Queens of Crime on Islands
Several of the Queens of Crime have written books set on islands – which may explain why its such a common device for authors today. I think at this point almost everyone knows that Agatha Christies And Then There Were None is set on an island, but it’s not the only one. If you’re a Poirot fan there is Evil Under the Sun. I’ve watched the movie version of this one loads (Peter Ustinov! Maggie Smith! Diana Rigg! Cole Porter music!) but it had been years since I read the book so I have had a re-read to remind me of the differences between the book and the film and although the movie makes some changes (including moving it from Devon to the Adriatic!) it’s more faithful to the book than I remembered it being and it’s a really good murder plot and solution.
If you’re a Miss Marple fan there is A Caribbean Mystery which sees Miss Marple’s holiday to a resort in the Caribbean (thanks to her nephew Raymond) turn deadly when one of her dinner companions dies – seemingly of natural causes but of course she isn’t convinced. This one of my personal least favourites of the series – but that’s mostly because the Joan Hickson TV adaptation version scared me witless when I was 11 to the point where I had to stop watching the adaptations all together! Even now, it’s the adaptation I rewatch the least – I’ve may be seen that one half a dozen times max, whereas with some of the others I’ve watched them so many times I can almost recite along with them – and have done a compare and contrast with the different edits available across different platforms because some of them are available as one giant episode as well as two or three individual ones. That said, I did go back and revisit it while I was writing this – and it is a pretty good mystery (once I disconnect the bits of my brain that remember the TV version) and really well put together.
If you’re a Ngaio Marsh reader, then Dead Water is set on an island where miracles are supposedly occurring at a spring. Now I’ve mentioned adaptations I should say that although this is one of the ones that was done by the TV series, but it has quite a lot of changes to the plot including the location of the island and the inclusion of Agatha Troy at all (let alone the point in the Alleyn-Troy relationship it occurs at). There’s also Last Ditch, which I have to say is one of my least favourites in the series and features grown-up Ricky (son of Alleyn and Troy) going to an island to try to get away from distractions so that he can write a novel and then getting kidnapped, forcing Alleyn to the rescue. Even later in the series there’s Photo Finish, where Alleyn and Troy are on a New Zealand island where a famous opera singer is trying to escape from the paparazzi. This is from the point in the series where you have to not think about how old Alleyn should be given that it is basically set in a contempoary period to it’s publication (1980!!!) but if you can manage that – which is much easier if you’re reading it in isolation rather than as is my habit as part of a read/listen through of the series – it’s pretty good.
If you want to read a Campion book there’s just the one: the second in the series, Mystery Mile, sees Albert trying to protect a judge from forces that are trying to kill him by hiding him on an island off the Suffolk coast. Margery Allingham set more of her series in London than Christie or Marsh – possibly because they can be more concerned with the criminal underworld and can tend towards the adventure story than the other two do.
Other authors
Islands are incredibly popular for mysteries as you can tell from the Queens of Crime – and so many other mystery authors have done them too it was an embarrasmment of riches putting this together. A lot of the cozy crime series have got island-set entries (as an homage to the Queens maybe?) including the second Meg Langslow book Murder with Puffins, Clammed Up the first in the Maine Clambake series, A Likely Story the sixth in the Library Lovers series and Susan M Boyer’s Liz Talbot series which are set on a South Carolina island. And of course there is (relatively) recent book of the week pick The Murder at World’s End, and Nicola Upson‘s The Dead of Winter which I mentioned in my Series at Christmas 2 post.
I have several island set mysteries on the pile waiting to be read – including Displeasure Island (the sequel to Grave Expectations), the first in the Death in Paradise tv-tie in series (which Robert Thorogood created and wrote before he started on the Marlow Murder series) and Rachel Rhys‘s Island of Secrets which is set on Cuba.
And that’s more than enough for today – Happy Humpday!
















