not a book, theatre

Not a Book: Oh Mary!

Another week, another theatre trip. And once again I’m posting slightly out of the order that I made them, for reasons that will become clear as the post goes on.

Oh Mary! is a dark comedy play written by Cole Escola, who originally also starred in it on Broadway. It tells the story of Mary Todd Lincoln, the wife of President Abraham Lincoln, in the days leading up to his assassination at Ford’s Theatre while watching Our American Cousin. In this telling, Mary is an angry alcoholic, trapped in an unhappy marriage with a deeply closeted man and is desperate to return to her glory days as a cabaret star. With me so far? It’s absurd, silly, sometimes gross and a little bit nasty too. It also won all the awards – off-Broadway and on Broadway when it started and was also a finalist for the Pulitzer prize for drama. It hit the West End last autumn, to not quite as enthusiastic reviews as Broadway and has been a hot ticket ever since. I snagged a ticket in on of the first flash sales I’d seen just a couple of weeks ago.

One of the things the show has become known for, both on Broadway and in the West End, the casting team have been making interesting choices for casting Mary, with people going back over and over to see the different interpretations of Mary. I read various theatre message boards and there was initially considerable scepticism about whether the show would be able to survive on Broadway without Escola in the leading role, but it did and has thrived. So much so that when it arrived in London Mary was played by Mason Alexander Park, although Escola has since come over and done a run*. The current London Mary is Lolly Adefope (of Ghosts fame) who has just a couple of weeks of her run to go before Jane Krakowski takes over (having already played the role on Broadway).

I’ve seen people compare this to The Play That Goes Wrong – and although they are both farces and have chaotic, over the top energy – I would strongly disagree. Oh Mary! is more adult, darker and much more cabaret and the comedy style is more obvious and crude. I’m not going to say that this is entirely my sort of humour (because I’d be lying) but I did laugh and I can see why it has done so well. If you gave me a choice of which I liked best, it would be The Play That Goes Wrong, but I would definitely consider going back to see Oh Mary again. That’s not because I loved the show so much but because I would like to see how someone else plays Mary, given that I’ve seen so much talk about how differently she can be interpreted depending on who is playing the role and because she has been played by such different people (other Marys have included Catherine Tate in the West End and Jinkx Monsoon in New York and London and Bowen Yang, Megan Stalter and Maya Rudolph on Broadway).

All of which is to say, this wasn’t an unqualified success for me, but as you can tell I had thoughts about it and it’s clearly a good show, even if it’s not entirely my style. I can see why it won the Best Entertainment or Comedy Play award at the Oliviers (beating The Comedy about Spies among others) because it is doing something different as well as something funny and it packs a lot into one 80-minute act. It’s maybe not one that I would recommend to everyone (I wouldn’t tell my mum to go and see it for example!) but I’ve seen shows this year that I wouldn’t recommend to *anyone* which is a whole different sort of thing. This is on at the Trafalgar Theatre, currently through til January 16th, but I suspect they will announce another extension and star casting before Christmas. I’ll keep you posted on if I go back and who I see if I do.

Have a great Sunday.

*I tried for tickets but no joy as they were all extremely expensive and i didn’t have any luck in on the day rush either an believe me I tried a lot