After doing Books with Sports earlier in the year and first sports romances post back in 2024, I’m back with a sequel because we are now deep into the Summer of Sport – England play Argentina tonight for a place in the World Cup Final on Sunday, the Wimbledon finals were last weekend and the Commonwealth Games start next week – I’ve got two sports romances for you too. And it’s only two because the reviews are slightly extended, because I had *a lot* to say!
Abby Offsides by Anna McCallie*
This is about an American social media manager who runs away to the UK and gets a job working on a Premier League club’s social accounts. The club is basically Liverpool (but it’s called Mersey) and soon Abby’s forming a friendship with the club’s latest signing – Lachlan – who is returning to the club he grew up at. When she has to move out of her flatshare, she moves into his spare room, but is it really a friendship or is there chemistry for something more? I think this is going to be a divisive one – and it’s worth noting that the blurb and cover are very different on the UK and US version. The UK cover is the one above – the US one is the one below.
The US is more women’s fiction coded, but the UK one has a very different sell and blurb – including on NetGalley where I got it from. And the difference is something so fundamental to the plot that I might not have requested it if I didn’t know about it – and that is that the hero is married. This isnt me Toones in the UK blurb, but the US one does has a reference: “despite the nagging guilt she feels about Lachlan’s mysterious wife who didn’t relocate with her husband.”
I’m not a hardcore no cheating in my novels person, but it’s a tricky line to tread. And the problem is that this is trying to tread it with a heroine who met the hero in the workplace, and is not acting at all professionally – beyond the wife issue, Abby is also keeping it a secret from her bosses that she’s living in his flat and to top it all off she’s working in sport, which is an area where women struggle to be accepted and treated as equals and has been told by her boss that they’re not interested in employing people who want to be WAGs. And yet, there she is. Oh and the whole reason she’s in the UK in the first place is because her fiancé cheated on her… I think under normal circumstances – with any other conflict at the centre of it – this would have been a book where I would have read it, and then realised afterwards when I was trying to analyse it that I had more issues with it than I thought. But because I was already analysing and thinking about the cheating issue I was reading with a more sceptical and critical lens than I might otherwise have been. But your mileage on this may vary depending on whether you were expecting “a novel” or “a romance”. This came out at the end of June and it’s 99p on Kindle and Kobo this month – so if you want to read it and tell me what you think, the outlay is small!
First and Forever by Lynn Painter
Duffy is a huge fan of her local NFL team, but she’s become enemy number one with the fans after she shoved the team’s mascot away from her for being a creep. She goes on to a TV show to try and clear her name – only to find herself face to face with Connor Cunningham, the team’s star player. The team is on a terrible run, but Connor is their star – and desperate to stay with the team who he suspects are going to trade their best players away as part of their rebuild plan*. So when the team ask him to take Duffy out on a date after their TV appearance generates some good press – he just can’t tell her what’s going on. You know where this is going.
This reads a bit new adult, and Duffy is a bit Not Like Other Girls as well as oblivious, but I’d rather have Duffy than Abby from the last book. A simple conversation could have fixed the issues in their relationship and Duffy’s family are terrible to her in a sort of oblivious way rather than a mean one, but it’s pretty readable and non-toxic NFL romance. Do I prefer the Chicago Stars series? Yes. But is it better than any of the Tessa Bailey Sports romances I’ve tried? Also yes. This is a pretty new release – it came out at the end of May and it’s also 99p on Kindle and Kobo at the moment, so again it’s not a big outlay and I liked this more than I liked Abby Offsides, so this one is more of a recommendation than the other one.
Also, this is a great opportunity to tell you that if you read that last post and remember me mentioning a massive hanging plot thread in the Simone Soltani book that the third book in that series, Crash Into You, comes out in August and is about the driver at the centre of that hanging plot thread – so we finally know that Zaid suffered two broken wrists which is not as life threatening as the first book implied (although definitely potentially career threatening) unless I’m missing something mega. Given that I didn’t love Cross the Line and the blurb for this says it’s also a pregnancy plot, I will probably give this one a miss – but that may well be right up some of your streets.
On the books I’d like to read front, Playing for Keeps by Alexandria Bellefleur which came out in January, is sports adjacent – featuring Poppy, a publicist for an NFL quarterback and Rosaline, the publicist for a popstar whose two client start a romance (yes, it’s also Tayvis adjacent) and I’ve got The Open Era on the Kindle although I’m not sure that’s actually a romance-romance for all that it’s recommended for “fans of Heated Rivalry and Challengers”.
Happy Humpday!
*This is an actual thing that NFL teams do try when they’re doing really, really badly – the Miami Dolphins seem to be currently trying it for the second time this decade!
Verity Reads Books (lots of them) 