Not a Book: Hillsong Documentaries

After writing about Scamanda a couple of months ago, this week we’re in another one of my special interest/fascination areas – mega churches. And the mega church in question here is Hillsong. Firstly for those of you who haven’t come across them before, Hillsong is a charismatic megachurch that started in Australia and spread through the world. They had a very successful music arm which wrote Christian pop and contributed to the church’s success, and then gained fame when one of their pastors, Carl Lenz became spiritual advisor to celebrities like Justin Bieber.

Hillsong first came to my attention when Vanity Fair ran an article about them in 2021 when a scandal blew up around the church’s charismatic pastor. And soon after a documentary popped up – and then in 2023 a second Vanity Fair article about them after a documentary series on Hulu. And as at the moment I’ve got both Disney+ and Discovery+ I’ve watched both of them and I’m here to give you my thoughts!

So the Discovery+ doc was the first one to come out – and covers the founding of the church, the rise and fall of Carl Lenz and other current day scandals and then the historic child sex abuse allegations. It has a final episode which came out six or so months after the first three and covers the fallout to the original three episodes.

The Secrets of Hillsong came out in 2023 and covers a lot of similar ground in terms of the founding of the church, the Carl Lenz scandal and the historic child sex abuse scandal. But what it has that the Discovery+ one doesn’t is interviews with Carl and his wife as well as the latest on the downfall of the church’s founder Brian Houston.

If you’re only going to watch one of these – and given that each is four parts, we’re talking about eight hours of your life if you watch all of both – then The Secrets of Hillsong is probably the one. And that’s mostly because of actually hearing from Lenz but also the fact that it covers some of the later allegations made against Brian Houston. But each of them had stuff that the other didn’t – so if you’re going to watch both, do it chronologically and watch Mega Church exposed first and then do Secrets of.

And if you’ve got any more documentaries (or podcasts) about mega churches or cults and their scandals, drop them in the comments for me, because I’m still fascinated!