Recommendsday: October Quick Reviews

Pinch, punch etc. Just the two for the quick reviews this month because it’s been a fairly re-read heavy month and I’ve already written about a lot of the new and new-to-me stuff! But hey, two is better than nothing right?

Death on the Down Beat by Sebastian Farr

Well this was a lot of fun. It’s both a musical mystery and a story told entirely through correspondence so that makes it a touch different to a lot of the other Golden Age Murder mysteries that you might come across. Our victim is a much-disliked conductor shot dead mid performance, seemingly without anyone seeing anything amiss until he keeled over. Our Detective is DI Alan Hope and the story is told thorugh the letters that he sends to his wife about the case – and the documents he includes in with that – which are a mix of letters from suspects, newspaper clippings and other similar items. It’s a really clever way of doing things – and it’s a shame that Farr never wrote any more, although I suspect it would not be an easy trick to pull off more than once. If you know a bit about music you’ll be able to follow this – I think if you know more about music than I do (grade 6ish clarinet and piano, bad at music theory) then you’ll get even more out of it. How it would work for a non-musician I don’t know!

A Lady’s Guide to Scandal by Sophie Irwin

As you might remember I read and really enjoyed Irwin’s first book when it came out last year, and so I’ve now come back to report in on her latest. My main critique of the first book was that there was just so. much. plot going on but that it moved so fast that you didn’t notice it. This second book doesn’t work as well – or at least didn’t for me – and the main culprits (I think) are that firstly that the two love interests in the heroine’s love triangle are both not great (at 50% I was wondering if we were going to get a late arriving third contender) and secondly that the heroine is just… hard to root for. She is both a pushover and ridiculously foolhardy by turns and it just gets very wearing really quite fast. And then – like the first book – it’s got a lot of plot, which leaves not a lot of time for it all to be resolved satisfactorily and when you don’t love the main characters you notice that. There’s a big revelation at more than 80% through that there is not time for a redemption for and the final resolution and reveal is just… too much too quickly. I’m sad I didn’t enjoy it more to be honest.

And of course there was a lot of other stuff too – including To Swoon and to Spar, Duke, Actually, 10 Things that Never Happened, Three Times a Countess and lots of Romances – M/m and on reality shows.

Happy Humpday!