Book of the Week: The Neighbor Favor

Is this the third week in a row that I’ve picked a romance set in the world of publishing or writing for my Book of the Week? Why yes. Clearly it’s as much of a theme in the genre at the moment as the ones where one half of the couple is famous. And of course Business or Pleasure had both!

Anyway, Kristina Forest’s The Neighbor Favor (yes it did bug me they didn’t change the spelling to the British English one!) has You’ve Got Mail vibes but manages to be a bit less catfish-y than a lot of those set ups feel these days. Lily’s sisters are successful over achievers. She’s stuck in an entry level publishing job in a genre that makes her miserable and with a boss that’s even worse. One night, a bit drunk, she emails the author of a little known fantasy novel, and to her surprise he writes back. This begins an email back and forth between Lily and Strick, who is a travel journalist and moving around all over the world. But then, suddenly, he ghosts her and she’s devastated. A few months later Lily is living in her sister’s apartment and meets a cute new neighbour, Nick. She doesn’t know it but Nick is Strick. Nick does figure it out pretty quickly though and tries to be the best friend he can to her – because he can’t be her boyfriend for: Romance Novel Reasons including but not limited to the fact she doesn’t know he’s her former penpal. And that’s as much as I’m going to tell you.

As you can tell from that, there’s enormous potential for this to go very wrong in the execution. But actually Forest pretty much pulls it off. Yes, I had a few minor quibbles, but it’s fairly minor compared to the throw-it-across-the-room-into-a-fire rage that some of the other books trying to do this have given me. Lily is an interesting character with her own share of issues, and Nick is an interestingly flawed hero. And of course it has plenty of bookish moments as well with Lily working in publishing and Nick being an author. Obviously, I’ve now read a bunch of similarly themed books and although I think if you forced me to chose one as my favourite it would probably be Business or Pleasure, this is still very good. And this is Forests’s adult debut so hopefully the start of more to come.

I picked the Neighbor Favor up for 99p on Kindle back in May, I think after seeing someone recommend it in the summer romance suggestions. It’s currently £2.99 on Kindle and Kobo and Amazon reckons there is a paperback, but I think it’s the US version imported because I haven’t seen it in the stores anywhere (yet at least).

Happy Reading!